South Africa: Simonstown Train Service Is Back, but Commuters Are Worried About Their Safety

Covid-19 was less of a threat than robbers for passengers on the train to Simonstown on Tuesday, with commuters huddled together in carriages for fear of attacks.

Commuters GroundUp spoke to were happy the train from Fish Hoek to Simonstown is operating again, after a long absence, but were worried about security.

In a statement on 19 December, Metrorail announced service resumption between Retreat and Fish Hoek stations after repair work due to cable theft in October. And on 4 January Metrorail announced the resumption of services between Fish Hoek and Simonstown.

I boarded the Metro carriage at 12.04 at Cape Town station, destination Simonstown. The trip costs R10, and ticket sellers are only selling single tickets, no weekly and monthly tickets, though these are more convenient and cost-effective for commuters.

At first the carriage was half empty, but it filled up as people boarded at the stations. Passengers ended up occupying spaces on seats marked “Do not sit here” to keep the commuters apart because of the Covid pandemic. When I asked why they did not use other carriages they mentioned the need to defend each other from robbers in case of an attack. They were wearing their masks.

At Retreat station, commuters panicked when doors failed to open but the doors later opened when the train was about to leave.

The journey from Cape Town to Simonstown took just over four hours and I didn’t see any security guards on the train. At Fish Hoek we had to get off the train and catch a “shuttle” train the remainder of the journey to Simonstown.

At Fish Hoek there was constant communication on Covid measures, train times and departure platforms. At Simonstown the ticket office was closed and there were no ticket checkers.

Adam Boote, 25, was traveling to Retreat after waiting for the train for half an hour at Woodstock. He was coming from a job interview. He said he was happy trains were operating again as he had been spending a lot of money on taxis. He also said children in his area were also happy to be able to use trains to the beach.

A taxi from Retreat to Cape Town costs R15. A taxi from Retreat to Fish Hoek is also R15, and it costs R12 to connect from Fish Hoek to Simonstown by taxi.

Boote said some commuters are hesitant to return to trains during peak hour because of previous experiences of delays, cancellation and trains stopping in the middle of nowhere. They need assurance that the train service has improved, he said. He said in October he waited for a train for about four hours and it didn’t come. Metrorail staff told him to wait, saying trains were delayed. He said other commuters went to take a taxi but he had to walk home because he didn’t have money for the taxi fare. He said since then he had become used to walking and rarely used taxis when trains are not operating.

A woman who only gave her name as Jane said she works two days in Fish Hoek and wanted to see if the train service had improved. She said she walks from Capricorn with her child who goes to school in Muizenberg. From Muizenberg she takes a train to Fish Hoek. While trains were not operating she was spending R13 on a taxi to Fish Hoek.

Michael was travelling from Fish Hoek to Simonstown. He said it is good that trains are back and commuters are saving money but emphasised that security issues needed to be sorted out. “We wish to see security and police patrolling on trains. We don’t feel safe.”

He said he had been on Metrorail’s new off-peak train once and he liked it. “It has a long passage and one can see all the way down. If the doors are open it won’t move, which makes it safe, and it announces every station the train is about to approach,” he said.